Kanchan Gupta, November 01, 2004
This week, light a candle in your window. And whisper a silent prayer in
memory of more than 4,000 Sikh men, women and children slaughtered by
Congress hoodlums 20 years ago. In Delhi alone, 2,733 Sikhs were burned
alive, butchered or beaten to death.
Women were raped while their terrified families pleaded for mercy,
little or none of which was shown by the Congress flag-bearers. In one
of the numerous such incidents, a woman was gang-raped in front of her
17-year-old son; before leaving, the marauders torched the boy.
For three days and nights the killing and pillaging continued without
the police, the civil administration and the Union government, which was
then in direct charge of Delhi, lifting a finger in admonishment. The
Congress was in power, and senior Congress leaders, perhaps for the
first time in their political careers, led from the front while the
prime minister, his home minister, indeed the entire council of
ministers, twiddled their thumbs.
Even as stray dogs gorged on rotting human entrails, gutters were
clogged with charred corpses and wailing women, clutching children too
frightened to cry, fled baying mobs armed with iron rods, staves and
gallons of kerosene, All India Radio and Doordarshan kept on
broadcasting blood-curdling slogans of 'Khoon ka badla khoon se lenge'
(We shall avenge blood with blood) raised by Congress party workers
grieving over their dear departed leader, India Gandhi.
Rajiv Gandhi, having ensconced himself as prime minister, later sought
to justify the terror unleashed by his party. Addressing a rally at
Delhi's Boat Club to celebrate his mother's birth anniversary, he
thundered: 'When a big tree falls, the earth will shake.' And shake it
did!
In mid-morning on October 31, 1984, Indira Gandhi was assassinated by
two Sikh guards posted at her home. The assassins, Satwant Singh and
Beant Singh, later said they had killed the prime minister to avenge the
Indian Army's assault on the Golden Temple -- Operation Bluestar -- at
her explicit instruction on June 5 that year. Beant Singh was killed by
the Indo Tibetan Border Police soon after Indira Gandhi's assassination.
Satwant Singh and an alleged accomplice, Kehar Singh, against whom there
was thin evidence, were executed for the crime.
Indira Gandhi's death was officially confirmed by All India Radio and
Doordarshan at 6 pm, after due dilligence had been exercised to ensure
Rajiv Gandhi's succession. By then, stray incidents of violence against
Sikhs, including the stoning of President Zail Singh's car, had started
trickling in at various police stations.
That night, the Congress party machinery went into a rumour-mongering
overdrive: in colony after colony (Delhi, the seat of India's colonial
rulers, is a sprawling conglomerate of 'colonies,' some upmarket, most
little more than shanty towns), rumours spread like wildfire, describing
in graphic details how 'Sikhs were distributing sweets to celebrate
Indira Gandhi's assassination,' how 'gurdwaras had been lit up as if it
were Diwali,' and, how 'Sikh terrorists had infiltrated the city.'
By the morning of November 1, hordes of men, shouting Congress slogans,
had started running riot in south, east and west Delhi. They were armed
with iron rods and carried old tyres and jerry cans filled with kerosene
and petrol. Owners of gas stations and kerosene stores, beneficiaries of
Congress largesse, provided petrol and kerosene free of cost. Some of
the men went around on scooters and motorcycles, marking Sikh houses and
business establishments with chalk for easy identification. They had
been provided with electoral rolls by their political masters to make
the task easier.
By late afternoon that day, hundreds of taxis, trucks and shops owned by
Sikhs had been set ablaze. By early evening, the killing, loot and rape
began in right earnest. The worst butchery took place in Block 32 of
Trilokpuri, a resettlement colony in east Delhi. Scores of families were
killed over November 1 and 2: most of them were despatched by putting
burning tyres around theirs necks.
The pogrom continued with the active abetment of the police. On November
1, some residents of Lajpat Nagar took out a peace march to thwart the
violence. The police stopped the march because the participants did not
have 'official permission.' In many places, police asked Sikhs to hand
over their kirpans, took them away forcibly if the Sikhs refused, before
the marauders descended upon them.
To prevent Sikhs from taking refuge in gurdwaras, most of Delhi's 450
gurdwaras were sacked in the early hours of the violence. The expedient
means of setting houses ablaze was used to get at Sikh families who had
taken refuge on the roofs of their homes. Entire families were roasted
alive.
A sort-of curfew was imposed in south and central Delhi at 4 pm on
November 1. But no action was taken in east and west Delhi and the
outlying area of Palam where the massacre of Sikhs was being carried out
with macabre ferocity and astounding impunity. Curfew was imposed in
east and west Delhi at 6 pm, ensuring that the killers had an extra four
hours.
P V Narasimha Rao, who was the home minister and responsible for
maintaining law and order in Delhi during those dark days, was fully
aware of what was happening. But he chose not to deploy the army in time
which could have prevented the pogrom. In his affidavit submitted to the
G T Nanavati Commission, inquiring into the pogrom, Lieutenant General
Jagjit Singh Aurora, much decorated hero of the 1971 war, has said, 'The
home minister was grossly negligent in his approach, which clearly
reflected his connivance with perpetrators of the heinous crimes being
committed against the Sikhs.'
The army was alerted at 2.30 pm on November 1; when the General Officer
Commanding went to meet the lieutenant governor for orders, he was kept
waiting for an hour. The first deployment of army jawans took place
around 6 pm on November 1 in south and central Delhi, which were
comparatively unaffected, but in the absence of navigators which should
have been provided by the police and the civil authorities, the jawans
found themselves lost in unfamiliar roads and avenues. The army was
deployed in east and west Delhi in the afternoon of November 2. But,
here, too, jawans were at a loss because there were no navigators to
show them the way through byzantine lanes.
In any event, there was little the army could have done: magistrates
were 'not available' to give permission to the jawans to fire on the
mobs. This mandatory requirement was kept pending till Indira Gandhi's
funeral was over. By then, 1,026 Sikhs had been killed in east Delhi,
the majority of the dead were residents of Block 32 in Trilokpuri.
The slaughter was not limited to Delhi. Sikhs were killed in Gurgaon,
Kanpur, Bokaro, Indore and many other towns and cities across India. In
a replay of the blood-letting in Delhi, 26 Sikh jawans and officers of
the Indian Army were pulled out of trains and killed. There has been no
effort to compute the death toll in these places, but the most
conservative estimates have placed it at 2,000.
After quenching their thirst for blood, the brave leaders of the
Congress and their foot soldiers retreated to savour their deeds of
revenge. The flames died, the smoke from smouldering shops and homes
lifted and the winter air blew away the stench of death. Rajiv Gandhi's
government, in a casual aside, issued an official statement placing the
death toll at 425.
Atal Bihari Vajpayee, who was then president of the Bharatiya Janata
Party, had instructed party leaders in Delhi to organise relief camps
and provide succour to the survivors of the pogrom. Madan Lal Khurana
and Vijay Kumar Malhotra had braved the marauders to move from colony to
colony, giving whatever help they could. Vajpayee contested the official
death toll and asked his colleagues to collate figures. Their total
added up to 2,800. 'The BJP is an anti-national party,' responded the
Congress.
There were demands for a judicial inquiry to fix responsibility and add
up the casualties. Rajiv Gandhi stonewalled these demands. Human rights
organisations petitioned the courts. Rajiv Gandhi's government declared
that courts were not empowered to order inquiries.
Meanwhile, Rajiv Gandhi dissolved the Lok Sabha and went for an early
general election. The Congress launched a vitriolic hate campaign
through advertisements and posters ('Can you trust a Sikh taxi
driver?'). In Rajiv Gandhi's constituency, Congress party workers raised
a rather telling slogan against his opponent and sister-in-law, Maneka
Gandhi: 'Beti hai Sardar ki, qaum hai gaddar ki' (She is the daughter of
a Sikh, a community of traitors).
Rajiv Gandhi rode the crest of a gigantic 'sympathy wave.' The Congress
won 401 seats in the Lok Sabha. The BJP was reduced to two seats,
punished for sympathising with the Sikhs.
By 1985, Punjab was fast slipping into a bottomless spiral of
secessionist violence and Rajiv Gandhi was desperate to show a
breakthrough. He mollycoddled Akali leader Sant Harchand Singh Longowal
into agreeing to sign a peace accord with him. Sant Longowal listed a
set of pre-conditions; one of them was the setting up of a judicial
inquiry into the anti-Sikh pogrom. Political expediency made Rajiv
Gandhi concede this and other demands (it is another matter that the
accord foundered and Sant Longowal was assassinated by terrorists).
Thus was born the Ranganath Mishra Commission that shall remain known
forever for white-washing official complicity and political patronage
without which the slaughter of Sikhs would not have been possible.
Submissions and affidavits were surreptiously passed on to those accused
of leading the mobs to facilitate their defence. Some of these documents
were later recovered from the house of Sajjan Kumar, one of the Congress
leaders who had been accused by victims in their signed affidavits. Gag
orders were issued, preventing the press from reporting in-camera
proceedings of the Commission.
For full six months, Rajiv Gandhi refused to make public the Ranganath
Mishra Commission's report. When it was tabled in Parliament, the report
was found to be an amazing travesty of the truth, an exercise that was
dedicated to drawing a bizarre distinction between Congress party
workers and the Congress party - the former were guilty, but not the
latter; no responsibility was fixed nor were the guilty named.
Subsequently, three other committees were set up: the Jain-Banerji
Committee to find out why cases were not registered by the police and,
if registered, why was it not done properly; the Kapoor-Mittal Committee
to look into the role of the police; and, the Ahuja Committee to compute
the number of deaths. The findings of the first two committees are
gathering dust in some corner of South Block.
The key finding of the Ahuja Committee is of relevance -- a total of
2,733 Sikhs were killed in Delhi. There is no record of an apology being
offered by either Rajiv Gandhi or his government for placing the death
toll at 425, leave alone for their description of the BJP as
'anti-national' because it had placed the figure at 2,800.
In these 20 years, nine commissions and committees have been set up to
look into different aspects of the anti-Sikh pogrom. Much bluster has
been heard about bringing the guilty to book. What we have seen is
inertia, political intervention and tardy prosecution. Overwhelming
evidence against Sajjan Kumar, Jagdish Tytler and H K L Bhagat has been
set aside by skulduggery and gerrymandering.
Two thousand seven hundred and thirty-three men, women and children
killed in Delhi, another 2,000 killed in other towns and cities, scores
of women raped, property worth crores of rupees looted or sacked.
Families devastated forever, survivors scarred for the rest of their
lives.
After 20 years, all that we have to show as justice being done is the
conviction of six men, who did not have the requisite financial or
political clout to manipulate their way to freedom and are serving
sentence for 'murder.'
Sajjan Kumar is back in business as a Congress member of the Lok Sabha;
Jagdish Tytler is minister for NRI affairs in the UPA government.
Those who survived the pogrom of 1984, haunted by nightmares of a
genocide the world has forgotten, wipe their tears in silence. |